China's Ministry of
Finance (MOF) has formulated and promulgated the
Financial Principles for Enterprises as well as
financial systems to be adopted by different trades.
The rules also apply to foreign-invested enterprises
(FIEs). Financial systems cover the following
aspects: revenue and expenditure, asset management,
cost management, criteria and approval procedures
for expenditure, foreign currency management,
internal control, and audit. This chapter will focus
on the regulations governing FIEs' financial
registration, establishment of financial accounting
department, investment capital, scope and uses of
expenses, liquidation, and advance recovery of
investment by the foreign investor.
6.1.1 Financial Registration
An FIE should apply to the financial authority
for financial registration within 30 days after
submission of application for business registration
or change of registration details. To apply for
financial registration, an enterprise should
complete the Financial Registration Form for
Foreign-invested Enterprises, supported by the
following documents: approval certificate for
establishment of an enterprise; feasibility study
report and its approval document; FIE contract
(agreement), articles of association (copy) and
their respective approval documents; business
licence (copy); and information on the FIE's
financial management system and related rules
formulated in accordance with the relevant state
regulations.
An FIE should submit its financial accounting
statements and status report of its financial
position to the competent financial or
administrative authority and local tax office on a
regular basis. The format, content and schedule for
submission should follow the relevant stipulations
by MOF. Annual financial statements and liquidation
reports should be accompanied by an auditor's report
prepared by Chinese certified public accountants
(CPAs).
6.1.2 Establishment of Financial
Accounting Department
FIEs should establish a financial accounting
department in the place where it is located, to be
manned by qualified financial and accounting
personnel responsible for handling financial and
accounting matters in accordance with the law. (MOF
has strict management guidelines regarding the
qualifications of financial and accounting
personnel.)
6.1.3 Investment Capital
To establish an enterprise, a certain amount of
capital is required as stipulated in the relevant
regulations and application for business
registration at the industry and commerce
administration departments is also necessary.
(a) Forms of Investment
Investors may make contribution to the registered
capital of an enterprise in cash, in kind, or in
intangible assets. Investors making contribution in
kind and in intangible assets must provide proof of
ownership and right of disposal, or other proof of
their validity as required by law. Investors are not
allowed to contribute leased assets or collateral
assets.
Investors making contribution in intangible
assets (excluding land-use rights) should provide
asset appraisal or valuation reports. In general,
the value of the contribution may not exceed 20% of
the total registered capital of the enterprise.
If foreign investors are making contribution in
cash, it should be in foreign currencies. However,
profits in renminbi made from investment in other
FIEs within the Chinese territory may be used as
contribution in cash.
When the full amount of registered capital has
been paid up, the FIE should appoint a Chinese CPA
to compile a capital verification report.
(b) Investment Recovery
In general, during the operation period of the
enterprise, investors are not allowed to withdraw
their share capital by any means except through
transfer of business as provided by law.
For Sino-foreign contractual joint ventures (JVs)
whose contract stipulates that all the fixed assets
should be handed over to the Chinese party upon
expiry of the JV, provisions can be made in the JV
contract that the foreign party may recover its
investment during the term of the JV. However, the
foreign party should still be jointly responsible
for the JV's liabilities in accordance with the
relevant laws and regulations as well as the
provisions of the contract. Any pre-tax investment
recovery should be reported to the competent
financial authority for examination and approval.
(c) Sources and Uses of Capital Reserve
The sources of an enterprise's capital reserve
include: the balance from investors' capital
contribution in excess of the prescribed amount of
registered capital; the balance resulting from the
different conversion/exchange rates used in the
assets account and the paid-up capital account;
income in the form of donations.
The designated uses of an enterprise's capital
reserve include: in the event of heavy losses where
the un-allocated profits of the previous year, the
reserve funds and development funds of the
enterprise are inadequate to make up for the
shortfall, the board of directors may pass a
resolution authorising the use of such funds in
making up for the losses; upon the board of
directors' decision and completion of the relevant
procedures, the funds may be used to increase the
capitalisation of the enterprise.
6.1.4 Assets Management
The recognition and measurement of assets have
been detailed in the section on the accounting
system. Summarised below are the administration
measures and procedures in relation to the use and
safekeeping of assets.
(a) Management of Current Assets
The cash of an enterprise should be kept by a
designated person; bank deposits should be
deposited into bank accounts opened in the name
of the enterprise.
- Prepayments and receivables
Prepayments and receivables should be handled
and collected in accordance with stipulations in
the contract or agreement.
Receipts, payments and deposits of foreign
currency capital should be handled in accordance
with the foreign exchange control regulations of
the state. Conversion between the foreign
currency and the accounting currency should be
carried out according to the relevant
regulations of the Ministry of Finance.
Inventory must be classified accurately,
priced reasonably and kept properly, with a
sound collection and return procedure and
regular stock-taking system in place.
In issuing or collecting merchandise,
self-produced semi-manufactures, raw materials,
finished products, and in collecting low-value
consumables and packaging materials, the
standard accounting treatment should be adopted
in calculating or amortising their actual costs.
For inventory with a face value greatly
different to its realisable net value and the
face value needs to be adjusted, adjustment can
be made by the enterprise upon approval granted
by the supervisory finance department or the
central government department in charge of the
industry.
- External Investment using tangible or
intangible assets
Enterprises using tangible or intangible
assets to invest in other enterprises must have
the assets re-valued. For short-term investment,
the difference between the re-valued amount and
the face value will be treated as loss for the
current period. But for long-term investment,
the difference would be treated as deferred
investment loss and would be amortised evenly on
a yearly basis during the investment period.
(b) Fixed Assets
- Fixed assets as investment input
For fixed assets used as investment input,
their account value should be the reasonable
price agreed in the contract or agreement, or
the price set according to market price plus the
relevant expenses involved. In determining the
value of the equipment contributed by the
investor as investment in kind in the
enterprise, the original invoice issued by the
equipment manufacturer should be produced.
Depreciation of fixed assets is generally
calculated using the straight line method or
production/service output method, depreciating
on a monthly basis starting from the month after
the fixed assets were first put into use. For
fixed assets which have ceased to be used,
depreciation would stop in the month after they
have ceased to be used. As for fixed assets
requiring other depreciation methods or change
in the existing depreciation method, approval
has to be sought.
Before proceeding with a construction
project, an enterprise must prepare its budget,
purchase the equipment and materials required,
carry out accurate project costing, make efforts
in saving project costs, and work out a project
completion plan.
(c) Intangible Assets
In calculating the value of intangible assets,
relevant detailed information must be available,
which includes copy of ownership certificate, bases
and standards for calculation etc. Valuation of
proprietary technology, franchise and goodwill must
be assessed and recognised by authorised
certification bodies or Chinese chartered
accountants.
6.1.5 Standards of Costs and Expenses and
Approval Procedures
(a) Costs and Expenses
Any payments in relation to the production and
operation of an enterprise should be treated as
costs and expenses.
(b) Wage Expenses
The levels of wage expenses under costs and
expenses are determined by the board of directors in
accordance with state regulations on FIE-related
labour management, taking into consideration the
economic benefits of the enterprise, and in
compliance with the principles of "pay according to
work and equal pay for same work".
(c) Insurance and Welfare for Chinese Staff
Insurance and welfare expenses for serving
Chinese staff can be treated as costs, expenses,
insurance and welfare and kept by the enterprise for
use in paying for the medical, insurance and welfare
expenses of serving staff.
(d) Retirement Fund and Unemployment Insurance
Fund for Chinese Staff
Pension and retirement fund and unemployment
insurance fund for Chinese staff set aside by the
enterprise in accordance with the standards set by
the government can be treated as costs and expenses
and handed over to the organisation in charge of
retirement and unemployment insurance for
management. The funds can only be used for labour
insurance and not for any other purposes.
(e) Housing and Cost of Living Allowances for
Chinese Staff
Allowances for housing and cost of living set
aside by the enterprise in accordance with the
standards set by the finance department and labour
department can be treated as costs and expenses.
Housing allowance should be retained by the
enterprise in the form of a subsidy fund and used
for subsidising the construction, maintenance and
purchase of housing for the Chinese staff. Cost of
living allowance should be handed over to the local
finance department.
(f) Entertainment Fee
Entertainment fee related to production and
operation paid from costs and expenses of the
enterprise must not be higher than the following
ceilings:
For enterprises engaged in industrial production,
agriculture, husbandry and commerce with annual net
sales of Rmb15 million or below, entertainment fee
should not exceed 0.5% of their annual net sales;
while those with annual net sales of over Rmb15
million, entertainment fee should not exceed 0.3% of
their annual net sales.
For enterprises engaged in tourism, catering,
transportation, construction, installation, design,
consultancy, finance, leasing and other services
with annual business revenue of Rmb5 million or
below, entertainment fee should not exceed 1% of
their annual revenue; while those with annual
business revenue of over Rmb5 million, entertainment
fee should be exceed 0.5% of their annual revenue.
For cross-sectoral enterprises, the ceiling of
entertainment fee should be calculated according to
the respective net sales or business revenue. Where
it is difficult to draw the line, entertainment fee
can be determined by the principal operation item
under the respective sector.
(g) Travel Allowance, Meal Allowance and
Director's Fee
The standards and management method for business
travel allowance, meal allowance and director's fee
should be determined by the board of directors at
reasonable levels and be reported to the supervisory
finance department or the central government
department in charge of the enterprise.
(h) Labour Union Fund
Enterprises should put aside 2% of their total
payroll each month as labour union fund, and this
item should be treated as costs and expenses. The
labour union fund is managed and used by the labour
union of the enterprise concerned according to the
relevant regulations of the All-China Federation of
Trade Unions
(i) Rebates (Commissions)
Rebates (commissions) received by enterprises in
accordance with contracts or agreements in the
course of their operation should be treated as
operation income or used to offset costs and
expenses. Rebates (commissions) paid in accordance
with contracts or agreements should be added to
costs and expenses.
6.1.6 Management and Distribution of
Income and Profit
(a) Recognition of Income
Income from the operation of an enterprise refers
to payment received or the right to receive payment
from products or merchandise sold, projects
completed, services or labour services provided.
In the case of a cooperative JV using product
sharing as the income distribution method, the
investors are considered to have realised their
income when they have received their share of the
products. The amount of such income is calculated as
per the sale price of the products sold to a third
party or as per the prevailing market price.
Except otherwise stated in the contract or
articles of association, the sale price of an
enterprise's export products (or merchandise) should
be ascertained by adding reasonable charges and
profit margins to the costs if such products (or
merchandise) are not directly sold by the
enterprise.
(b) Profit Distribution
- Order of priority for profit distribution
Enterprises should pay income tax on the
profits they earn in accordance with the law.
After-tax profits should be distributed in the
following order of priority:
(i) Paying all kinds of fines such as
breach-of-contract fines, late charges, late
interest charges and other penalties;
(ii) Making up for previous years' losses;
(iii) Contributing to reserve funds, enterprise
development funds, staff incentives and welfare
funds;
(iv) Profit distribution to investors.
- Principles of profit distribution to
investors
Equity JVs should distribute profits
according to the actual proportion of capital
contribution by the respective investors;
cooperative JVs should follow the terms as
stated in their contracts; whereas foreign
enterprises should do so according to their
articles of association.
Investors failing to honour their contractual
obligations in terms of capital contribution as
stipulated in state regulations or other
provisions in the contract will not be eligible
for profit distribution.
- Conversion of profit in renminbi and profit
repatriation
Unless otherwise stated in the contract or
articles of association, profit to be
distributed in cash is on principle in the
currency of the income from the enterprise's
operation. Investors may convert their profit in
renminbi into foreign currencies but have to be
responsible for the possible profit and/or
losses in currency exchange.
Foreign investors may remit their profit
overseas, or they may reinvest it in China.
(c) Reserve Fund, Enterprise Development Fund,
Staff Incentive and Welfare Fund
The ratios of contribution to reserve funds,
enterprise development funds, staff incentives and
welfare funds are determined by the board of
directors. Among these, reserve funds must account
for at least 10% of an enterprise's after-tax
profits. When the reserve funds reach 50% of the
enterprise's registered capital, further
contribution is not required. It is not mandatory
for an enterprise to set aside an enterprise
development fund.
Reserve funds are intended primarily to make up
for an enterprise's operating losses. Development
funds are usually used for expanding the
enterprise's scale of production or operation; and
upon approval by the original approval authority,
such funds may also be used to increase investment.
Staff incentives and welfare funds are earmarked for
ad hoc incentive programmes and collective benefits
such as subsidies for the purchase, construction,
maintenance and repair of staff housing.
6.1.7 Liquidation
(a) Liquidators and Their Responsibilities
Upon dissolution of an enterprise in accordance
with the contract, articles of association or due to
other reasons, a liquidation committee should be
formed within 15 days. In general, the liquidation
committee should consist of directors of the
enterprise and representatives of the creditors.
Chinese CPAs or lawyers may also be hired to sit on
the committee. If deemed necessary, the competent
financial authority may send its staff to supervise
the work of the committee. If the enterprise
declares bankrupt, the case should be filed with the
people's court for bankruptcy proceedings.
After the liquidation committee announces the
liquidation of the enterprise, it will inform the
creditors who will declare the outstanding debts
owed to them within a specified period. The
committee will then draw up a liquidation plan,
prepare balance sheets and other financial
statements, assets lists, debts and liabilities
lists, and give its opinions to the board of
directors on asset disposal. Upon approval by the
board of directors, the liquidation plan will be
filed with the competent financial and
administrative authorities for the record and
implementation.
(b) Liquidation Assets and Valuation
Liquidation assets include all the properties of
the enterprise at the time of announcing the
liquidation and the assets acquired during the
liquidation period. However, three types of assets
are excluded: first, the balance in the staff
incentives and welfare funds and housing funds for
mainland workers, and all properties and facilities
purchased or constructed with such funds; second,
the balance in the enterprise's insurance and other
benefits for its mainland workers; third, the
balance in the enterprise's trade union funds and
the properties purchased or constructed with such
funds.
The price of liquidated assets is normally
determined on the basis of the net face value of the
assets. It may also be determined by re-evaluation
or by the amount of cash obtained from the sale of
the assets.
(c) Debt Repayment Responsibility
Enterprises with legal entity status in China
(that is, limited liability companies and joint
stock limited companies) should repay their debts
with all the companies' registered assets. For
enterprises without the status of a legal entity,
the investors involved should bear unlimited
liability for debt repayment and other related
liabilities.
In a Sino-foreign cooperative JV where it is
stipulated in the contract that the foreign party
can recover its investment with priority during the
term of the cooperation and that all the fixed
assets will be handed over to the Chinese party upon
expiry of the JV, both the Chinese and foreign
parties should be jointly liable for debt repayment
in the event of liquidation.
(d) Order of Priority in Debt Repayment
After all liquidation expenses are paid up, debts
will be repaid in the following order of priority:
(i) Overdue workers' wages and labour
insurance fees;
(ii) Overdue national taxes;
(iii) Overdue debts.
(e) Distribution of Residual Assets
In a liquidation exercise, after deducting all
the debts and losses, the residual assets will be
used to cover undistributed profits, capital
surplus, other funds and the liquidation expenses.
After all these deductions, the balance that exceeds
the amount of the paid-up capital is the net
liquidation proceeds, which will be deemed as profit
and, as such, subject to income tax. The residual
after-tax assets will be distributed to investors
according to the following order of priority:
For equity JVs, distribution would be made
according to the actual proportion of capital
contribution of the respective investors. For
cooperative JVs, distribution would follow the terms
stated in their contracts and articles of
association. For foreign enterprises, distribution
would be made according to their articles of
association.
(f) Cancellation of Financial Registration
When the liquidation process is complete, the
liquidator will present a liquidation report
accompanied by an income and expenditure statement
for the liquidation period, and a verification
report by a Chinese CPA, to the competent financial
authority, and proceed with cancellation of the
financial registration of the enterprise.
6.1.8 Regulations Governing FIEs
Implementing the Accounting System for Business
Enterprises
The Accounting System for Business
Enterprises promulgated by the Ministry of
Finance on 29 December 2000 became effective for
FIEs starting from 1 January 2001. At the same time,
the Accounting System for Foreign Investment
Enterprises of the People's Republic of China
and its related regulations governing account titles
and financial statements promulgated by the Ministry
of Finance on 24 June 1992 were revoked. The
regulations governing the Accounting System for
Business Enterprises for FIEs are as follows:
(a) Implementation of the Accounting System
for Business Enterprises by FIEs has resulted
in changes in the accounting policies adopted. Apart
from the following items which adopt the retroactive
adjustment method, all other changed items adopt the
prospective application method:
- Short-term investment impairment reserve,
long-term investment, fixed assets, intangible
assets, work-in-progress and trust lending
impairment reserve under the Accounting
System for Business Enterprises.
For the balance between receivables bad debt
reserve and inventory impairment reserve under
the Accounting System for Business
Enterprises and that under the old system,
the retroactive adjustment method is adopted.
- For investments made before the
implementation date of the Accounting System
for Business Enterprises and are still
valid on the date of implementation, they should
be handled according to the regulations of the
Accounting System for Business Enterprises
starting from the day the system was
implemented. In other words, all investments and
investment proceeds recognised in accordance
with the Accounting System for Foreign
Investment Enterprises before the
implementation of the Accounting System for
Business Enterprises are not subject to
retroactive adjustment. However, any subsequent
recognition of investment proceeds and
adjustment to investment face value should be
handled in accordance to the Accounting
System for Business Enterprises.
- In implementing the Accounting System
for Business Enterprises, if the
unamortised organisation expenses and the
construction period exchange loss balance of the
FIE are substantial and the direct transfer of
which to the income statement of the current
period creates a great impact on the profit of
the enterprise, they can be handled using the
retroactive adjustment method. But if such
amounts are relatively small and the direct
transfer of which to the income statement of the
current period does not create a great impact on
the profit of the enterprise, such balances can
be transferred to the income statement of the
current period directly.
(b) Any other issues arising from the
implementation of the Accounting System for
Business Enterprises by FIEs can be handled as
follows:
- Balance under "Marketable Securities" is
transferred to "Short-term Investment".
- Balance under "Prepayment" and balance under
"Advance Collection" are transferred to
"Accounts Prepaid" and "Advance Receipt"
respectively.
- Balance under "Inventory Realisation Loss
Reserve" is transferred to "Inventory Impairment
Reserve".
- Credit balance under "Construction Period
Exchange Loss" should be treated on a
case-by-case basis: for balance to be settled at
the time of liquidation, it should be
transferred to "Long-term Prepaid Expenses"; for
balance to be used to offset the losses incurred
during the current financial year in the
production and operation of the enterprise, it
should be transferred to "Long-term Prepaid
Expenses"; for balance to be amortised equally
in the five years starting from the year the
enterprise commenced production and operation,
if its direct transfer to the income statement
of the current period creates a great impact on
the profit of the enterprise, it can be handled
using the retroactive adjustment method; but if
such direct transfer does not create a great
impact on the profit of the enterprise, the
balance can be transferred to the income
statement of the current period directly.
- Other deferred expenses balances should be
treated according to different circumstances:
for items that can benefit the subsequent
accounting period, they should be transferred to
"Long-term Prepaid Expenses"; for those that
cannot benefit the subsequent accounting period,
they should be transferred to the income
statement of the current period directly.
- Balance under "Deferred Investment Loss"
should be treated according to different
circumstances: credit balance should be
transferred to "Long-term Prepaid Expenses";
debit balance should be transferred to "Deferred
Income".
- Payable company debt, payable company debt
premium and impairment balance should be
transferred to "Payable Bonds".
- Balance under "Payable Wages" (or "Payable
Wages and Welfare") should be treated according
to different circumstances: if it falls under
the total payroll payable to the staff
(including all kinds of wages, bonuses and
allowances under the total payroll), it should
remain under "Payable Wages"; but if falls under
funds such as pension for the Chinese staff,
welfare and insurance expenses and various
allowances stipulated by the state, it should be
transferred to "Payable Welfare Expenses".
- For "Payable Welfare Expenses", apart from
the various items transferred from "Payable
Wages", they also cover bonuses and welfare fund
set aside by the FIE from its after-tax profits.
Other welfare expenses should be entered
directly under the income statement of the
current period.
- Balances under "Reserve Fund", "Enterprise
Development Fund" and "Profit Capitalised on
Return for Investment" are transferred to
"Surplus Reserve".
- The item "Deferred Income" is added under
"Projected Liabilities" in the balance sheet.
- Under "Paid-in Capital" in the balance
sheet, the item "Of which: investment by the
Chinese party (closing balance of non-renminbi
capital) and investment by the foreign party
(retained non-renminbi capital)" is added.
- For foreign-invested tourism enterprises, on
the basis of the Accounting System for Business
Enterprises, their income statement and
supporting statements should be prepared in
accordance with the formats stipulated in the
Account Titles and Financial Statements of
Foreign Investment Tourist Enterprises.
(c) In preparing comparative financial statements
adopting the retroactive adjustment method, if any
accounting policy change occurs during the periods
the comparative financial statements are prepared,
the net profit and loss and other relevant items
should be adjusted accordingly. For any cumulative
effect arising from policy change in the previous
comparable periods, adjustment should be made to the
retained income brought forward in the comparative
financial statements. The amount of other relevant
items in the financial statements should also be
adjusted at the same time.